rub-ber-stamp [ruhb-er-stamp] -verb (used with object) 1. To imprint with a rubber stamp. 2. To give approval automatically without consideration: to rubber- stamp the president’s proposals.
Nothing more accurately portrays the concept of rubber-stamping than the performance evaluations of Kentucky’s school district superintendents. Kentucky’s recent National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) proficiency rates in math, reading and writing were abysmal. According to the NAEP, little more than one out of three fourth-grade students are proficient in math and reading, while in eighth grade, the most recent data show scarcely more than one in four students are proficient in math and writing.
Furthermore, a 2010 news release from the Kentucky Department of Education identified 13 school districts that failed to make Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP) under No Child Left Behind for an astonishing eight years or more. Eight years! Think about how many students graduated in that time and suffered through their school district’s underperformance.
Still, regardless of performance, Kentucky superintendents generally receive rave reviews that are not based on the achievement of goals and school performance. For example, Jefferson County Public Schools Superintendent Sheldon Berman, whose salary is $260,000 a year plus benefits, was praised by his board in May 2010 for his talent as an “engaging public speaker” and in the area of labor relations. Meanwhile, thousands of children are getting left behind in their educational opportunities in the 41 schools in Berman’s district that failed to make AYP in 2009. The JCPS school board’s evaluation of Berman is long on flowery language about Berman’s speaking qualities but short on measurable results. Yet somehow – despite the results – these evaluations almost always are accompanied by a salary increase.
You can view all of the requests/evaluations obtained in 2010 here.
- Fayette County 2011 evaluation - No evaluation available
- Fleming County 2011 evaluation - View the 2011 performance evaluation in pdf
- Hopkins County 2011 evaluation
- Lee County 2011 evaluation - - View the 2011 performance evaluation in pdf.
- Lincoln County 2011 evaluation
- Livingston County 2011 evaluation - View the 2011 performance evaluation in pdf.
- McCreary County 2011 evaluation - View the 2011 performance evaluation in pdf.
- Monticello Independent 2011 evaluation
- Pulaski County 2011 evaluation
- Simpson County 2011 evaluation - View the evaluation in PDF
- Trimble County 2011 evaluation
- Rewarding Failure: Round #2 October 25, 2011
- McCreary Superintendent evaluation includes student achievement September 28, 2011
- View the SPARSE Knox Co. superintendent evaluation July 6, 2011
- Campbellsville Independent superintendent’s performance is perfect?? June 25, 2011
- Knox County superintendent's perfect score? June 22, 2011
- Rewarding failure: Fayette County Public Schools June 20, 2011
- Superintendent reviews changing? June 20, 2011
- Newport Independent superintendent steps down June 7, 2011